Friday, December 28, 2012

Aida, Metropolitan Opera HD Live, Dec. 15 2012

To the best of my recollection, this is the first opera to be broadcast a second time on the Met’s HD Live series, the previous broadcast being the one of Oct. 24 2009, with Violeta Urmana, Johan Botha, Dolora Zajick, and Daniele Gatti, in the same Sonja Frisell production. This production dates back to 1988, and is a “classic” production with nothing outlandish.

Act 1 Scene 1 took place in front of a large tan stone wall, or rather three walls delimited by two square columns. The middle wall was somewhat recessed, allowing the various characters to enter and exit by slipping behind the left and right walls. For Scene 2, the walls were removed to reveal the Temple of Pthah, where Radames received his commission as the general of the Egyptian army. This time the wall was against the back of the stage, with various stone platforms jutting out from it. In the center, supported ten feet above the stage by the wall structure, was some sort of idol; from its space, ramps led upwards to the left and right.

Act II Scene 1, Amneris’s chambers, featured another stone wall with Egyptian paintings on it. In the center, a small raised platform was marked at its front corners by square pillars, and on this platform was Amneris’s chaise longue. The transition to Scene 2 was accomplished by lowering the “crown moulding” from on high down to stage level, while the wall and chaise longue were dropped into the basement. The Triumphal March took place in front of a structure that vaguely resembled Abu Simel, with Egyptian gods and hieroglyphs carved into a massive wall upstage, with another raised platform for the King of Egypt and his daughter, Amneris. There were no elephants, or even props made to suggest elephants, but there were horses. Six trumpet players shared the King’s reviewing stand; they played loooooong ceremonial trumpets.

Act III was set on the banks of the Nile. On the left, an entryway and steps led into the Temple of Isis, where Amneris prayed before her wedding ceremony. On the right were rocks as tall as a human, with a path wending among them. The painted backdrop showed a low but extensive structure on a hill on the other side of the Nile; on our side of the Nile were many plants, perhaps papyrus bushes.

Act IV Scene 1, in which Amneris offers to save Radames if he will give up his love for Aida, was played in front of yet another stone wall. Scene 2, the trial of Radames, featured a large stone plaza surrounded by stone pillars, with a couple of stone pillars in the interior. Scene 3, the tomb, was somewhat of an echo of Act 1 Scene 1, with a middle wall recessed behind left and right walls, allowing Aida to appear from the depths of the tomb. But the tomb was only half the height of the stage; the ceiling of the tomb formed the floor of the surface on which Amneris could walk back and forth, lamenting her fate.

Our cast:

Aida: Liudmyla Monastyrska
Amneris: Olga Borodina
Radamès: Roberto Alagna
Amonasro: George Gagnidze
Ramfis: Štefan Kocán
The King: Miklós Sebestyén
Conductor: Fabio Luisi
Production: Sonja Frisell
Set Designer: Gianni Quaranta

The Met, of course, presented a spectacular Triumphal March, with a cast of what seemed like hundreds, though we learned at intermission that supers would march across the stage in one costume, do a quick change, and march across again in a different guise. As for the singing, only Olga Borodina’s Amneris of Act IV Scenes 1 and 2 and George Gagnidze’s Amonasro of Act 2 Scene 2 offered much to get excited about. On the whole, the production was entertaining but rarely moving, somewhat short of a beta.





Wednesday, December 12, 2012

La Clemenza di Tito, Metropolitan Opera HD Live, Dec. 1 2012

San Francisco Opera performed Mozart’s almost-final opera (it premiered 3½ weeks before The Magic Flute) in 1993, and it didn’t make much of an impression on me then. But with nearly 20 more years of opera experience under my belt, including Idomeneo, and with notable performers such as Elina Garanca, Barbara Frittoli, and Kate Lindsey, it was worth a short drive and a few bucks to give La Clemenza di Tito another try. Definitely better the second time around!

No radical director “concepts” were in evidence here. Every scene was a variation on a basic set comprising two levels of stage, with a semicircular series of steps to connect the front and the back, and stone arches and columns in abundance, with a large arch in the center of the back wall. Inside this arch were placed various objects appropriate to the action of the scene: a large bed in the opening scene, a ship (on rails) for Berenice’s departure, a statue, etc. 

Our cast: 

Servilia: Lucy Crowe
Vitellia: Barbara Frittoli
Sesto: Elina Garanca
Annio: Kate Lindsey
Tito: Giuseppe Filianoti
Publio: Oren Gradus

Conductor: Harry Bicket
Production: Jean-Pierre Ponnelle


I’ve been a fan of Kate Lindsey ever since her knockout performance as Nicklausse in The Tales of Hoffman (Met HD Live broadcast Dec. 2009), and again she was superb. Her duet with Servilia (Lucy Crowe) was ravishing. Elina Garanca certainly has a wide range of characters. I’ve seen her as Cenerentola, Carmen, and now the pants role of Sesto, and each time she was outstanding. To think that, prior to La Cenerentola, I said “Elina Garanca? Who’s that?” Now I know, and you can count me as one of her fans too. Barbara Frittoli sang very well, but was somewhat overshadowed by those first two. Definitely a beta.

Tosca, San Francisco Opera, Nov. 29 2012

After seeing the Angela Gheorgiu Tosca on Nov. 18, and reading a review of the other cast (with Patricia Racette) that started “What a difference a change in cast makes!” I picked up a ticket to see that other cast. 

The other cast:
Tosca: Patricia Racette
Cavaradossi: Brian Jagde
Scarpia: Mark Delavan
Angelotti: Christian van Horn
Sacristan: Dale Travis
Conductor: Nicola Luisotti
Director: Jose Maria Condemi

The main thing that I learned from this performance is to avoid the ultra-low-priced seats in the back corner of the second balcony. There is a reason that they are priced so low. 

As in the first cast, the Scarpia was the most impressive. This time it was Mark Delavan, in fine voice, though without the tremendous depth of villainy that Lado Ataneli gave us in the summer of 2009. Brian Jagde’s Cavaradossi was somewhat marginal in Santa Fe a few months ago, and my hopes for a quantum improvement for San Francisco were not realized. Patricia Racette sang well, but without reaching the heights of her 2007 Cio-Cio San. Too bad that Angelotti has such a small part, I would have loved to hear more of Christian van Horn. It’s still somewhat short of a beta, though my inferior seat may have a lot to do with that judgment.