Mozart last night; brand-new opera this afternoon. David Gockley’s project to bring the book “Heart of a Soldier” to the operatic stage, a project initiated when he was director of Houston Grand Opera, finally came to fruition. The book tells the life story of Rick Rescorla, the head of security for Morgan Stanley, who led 2700 employees in the World Trade Center to safety after the attacks of Sept. 11, only to lose his own life when he went back to search for stragglers. The opera, by composer Christopher Theofanidis and librettist Donna DiNovelli, follows the book very closely. Of course, with only 1 hour 40 minutes of music, some of the details have to be omitted, but nearly all of the important events do make it to the stage.
The backdrop for the entire production is a representation of the Twin Towers. We see four stories of each building, each with seven bays facing the audience; the insides are bare except for people and the emergency exit stairway. The towers will be obscured by drop-downs from time to time, but the physical structures stay in place through both acts.
Act 1 opens with the young Cyril (Rick’s actual given name, he adopted “Rick” in honor of the American soldiers) making friends with the American soldiers who were in Cornwall preparing for D-Day. In the next scene, we see the inside of a bar in Rhodesia, with walls of corrugated sheet metal, where Rick meets his life-long friend Dan Hill. Rick is borne in on the shoulders of other men; they are all celebrating his killing of a lion that has been menacing the local village. Rick shouts “Who is ready to wrestle the strongest man in Rhodesia?” and the first words of Dan Hill are “I’m ready to wrestle the second strongest man in Rhodesia!” (The pre-performance talk had advised us that yes, there were humorous lines, and despite the serious nature of the story, we should feel free to laugh at the right times.)
There is a brief scene in Ft. Benning, Georgia, where Rick and Dan are in Officer’s Candidate School. An ordinary rigging pole descends from on high and a number of men use it to do pull-ups. (I heard that these supers were super-athletes, capable of 100 pull-ups and 200 push-ups, and magnificent physical specimens, though we only got to see their backs.) Then it’s off to Viet Nam, with another large piece of corrugated metal with a jagged gash through it serving as the backdrop, while projections of jungle plants are displayed on it. The final scene depicts Rick’s wedding to “a bride” who has no music to sing. We see a number of large round tables set for a wedding reception, and Rick and his bride enter through an archway of crossed swords. The women tend to gather on the left side of the stage, Rick and his military buddies on the right side, echoing the point made in the book that Rick paid little attention to his bride at the reception.
After intermission, the twin towers are on full display, as Rick leads his charges in evacuation drills. Dan Hill is there, describing what it would take to bring down the towers. (Dan had eerily predicted both the 1993 truck bomb in the basement of WTC, as well as the 2001 attacks.) Then there is an interlude where we see Susan, who will become Rick’s second wife, relaxing in the park with her dog. The only suggestion of a park is a large red fire hydrant mounted on a short platform. Rick comes by, jogging in his bare feet (he’s writing a book on a barefoot runner), meets Susan, and before long they are having coffee. Then it’s back to WTC. The stage towers do not actually fall (this is not an updated version of Samson and Dalila), but the destruction is represented by lights suddenly going off, emergency lights coming on, and lots and lots of paper floating down from on high. In a short epilog, without voices, Dan Hill and Susan Rescorla kneel and smear their arms with concrete dust, echoing Rick’s ritual of smearing his skin with the blood of the lion he had killed in Rhodesia, the idea being to acquire the strength that the dead had possessed.
Our cast:
Rick Rescorla: Thomas Hampson
Dan Hill: William Burden
Susan Rescorla: Melody Moore
(and 28 minor characters)
Conductor: Patrick Summers
Director: Francesca Zambello
Thomas Hampson was involved with the project nearly from the beginning, and he portrayed his character perfectly with his acting and singing and craggy good looks. William Burden and Melody Moore supported him ably. This time, Zambello’s staging was spot-on, perfectly suited to the material at hand, and avoiding the directorial conceit so much in evidence in San Francisco’s Ring of a few months ago.
But how was the music? Lots of people are afraid of modern opera, and often with good reason. What little of Theofanidis's other music I have heard suggests “movie music,” which is not necessarily bad; it certainly goes down better than Berg and Schoenberg and Ligeti. Here the music serves the story well, without calling attention to itself unduly. Much of the vocal line is almost recitative. Rick gets one full-blown aria, in the second act, the thrust of which I forget.
How was the story? As previously mentioned, the libretto was very true to the book. The librettist did leave out a lot of the Viet Nam story, but wisely so. Going in, I had my concerns about an opera comprising lots of little scenes (there is a prologue and five scenes before intermission), based on last year’s Anna Karenina at Opera San Jose, whose 19 separate scenes seemed rather disjointed. These scenes were long enough to be more than thumbnail-size stories, and though there was no smooth transition between the scenes (note that we jumped from the jungles of Viet Name to Rick’s first wedding), the story line worked. The details of the libretto, however, left a bit to be desired. There were too many rhyming couplets, and I do have to credit the line “I’m going to have to give you a geography lesson” as being as mundane as “Who was that on the telephone?” (Angle of Repose, Andrew Imbrie, 1976).
Bottom line: I enjoyed it. It’s definitely one of the better modern operas that I have seen, though Götterdämmerung has nothing to worry about. I’m looking forward to seeing it again in a few days. A beta.
Thursday, September 22, 2011
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Idomeneo, Opera San Jose, Sept. 17 2011
Idomeneo is Mozart’s 11th opera, and his first great one. It’s rarely performed, perhaps because of the staging demands, perhaps because of the modern public’s lack of appetite for opera seria, an operatic form that was already going out of style in Mozart’s day. But based on this Opera San Jose production, it deserves far more exposure than it has today.
The Packard Humanities Foundation funded a historically accurate production. The foundation’s director, David Woodley Packard, is a professor of classics, with a particular interest in the time and place in which Idomeneo is set: the island of Crete, approximately 1200 BC, right after the Trojan War. Packard brought his knowledge of art and architecture, and that of his professional colleagues, to the production, ranging all the way from the massive set near the end of Act 3 down to the earrings worn by the performers. And scuttlebutt has it that more was spent on this one production than Opera San Jose normally spends in an entire year of four productions. There was even enough funding to permit a complete performance, no need to cut any music in order to bring the show in under 3 hours (I measured 3 hours 35 minutes).
Act I opens in the royal palace, with walls and columns decorated with historical authenticity. The palace floor consists of light brown, almost sandy, 4 ft x 4 ft tiles, which also serve well for the following scene at the seashore. Idomeneo and his shipmates have landed safely on the beach after surviving the wreck of their ship, whose mast and tattered sail can be seen upstage. The beach and ship are surrounded by a semicircular diorama.
Act 2 continues the diorama theme, but now the diorama is informed by the artwork from a piece of decorated 17th century BC pottery depicting the ships of the era. The original artwork was about 16 inches on a side; it has been very effectively recreated in large scale to fill the back of the stage. The scene change takes us back to the royal palace, but a different part, the king’s chambers, consisting of painted (though not decorated) walls and pillars, and a low bench for the king to sit on. Another scene change takes us back to the diorama, this time fairly abstract, looking crinkled cellophane. When the storm hits at the end of the act, strobe lights on the cellophane do a good job of depicting the storm.
Act 3 opens in a very simple set, apparently downstairs in the palace. It looks like a small room, seen at a 45° angle; through an open doorway (without door) we can see steps leading to the upper level of the palace. The scene changes to the most impressive one of the evening: a massive set representing the exterior of the palace of Knossos, again with walls and pillars, but there are (at least) three levels, with people standing on all the levels. (I had heard reports of four levels, but from the Grand Tier I could only see three.) In my preview I had made mention of the fact that Mozart saved the trombones for near the end, bringing them in to preface an announcement from The Voice. In this performance, we don’t get trombones, we get a thunderous statement from the Mighty Wurlitzer installed at the California Theatre, originally a 1927 movie palace. I read that for this performance they installed four new 32-foot organ pipes. (The organ could use more of them, but this performance only needed those four notes.) Following Elettra’s final aria, Idomeneo sings an aria in front of the curtain (and in front of a drop-down panel of artwork), an aria not included in my commercial recording. This aria has covered the final scene change, where they get rid of the palace and return us to the diorama, this time with three copies of a piece of art depicting bull-leaping.
Our cast:
Idomeneo: Alexander Boyer
Idamante: Betany Coffland
Ilia: Sandra Bengochea
Elettra: Jasmina Halimic
The Voice: Silas Elash
Conductor: George Cleve
Director: Brad Dalton
It was a fine cast to go along with a fine production. Everyone sang well, but I was particularly taken with the intense portrayals of Idamante and Elettra by Coffland and Halimic. Elettra is a particularly juicy role, she has a couple of rip-roaring arias to express her extreme displeasure at a Trojan slave (Ilia) rather than her, a Greek, being the one that Idamante is in love with. I had expected The Voice to be amplified and perhaps electronically modified, but Elash's sonorous bass voice filled the hall. It’s unfortunate that we got to hear The Voice for only about two minutes. (I had wondered where The Voice would spend the first two acts; he is not called for, and then does not even appear, until near the end of Act 3. As second intermission began, I ran into Elash descending from the upper balcony, on his way to his warm-up.) George Cleve, our local Mozart expert, led a first-rate orchestra.
Fantastic sets, wonderful costumes, great singing and playing, and first-class Mozart—what’s not to like? Well, the libretto, written by the chaplain at the court of Salzburg, something of an amateur at libretto-writing. Mozart’s music is superb at a moment-by-moment level, but as an entire work of art, it failed to leave a tremendous impact at the end of the evening. Somewhere between an alpha and a beta.
The Packard Humanities Foundation funded a historically accurate production. The foundation’s director, David Woodley Packard, is a professor of classics, with a particular interest in the time and place in which Idomeneo is set: the island of Crete, approximately 1200 BC, right after the Trojan War. Packard brought his knowledge of art and architecture, and that of his professional colleagues, to the production, ranging all the way from the massive set near the end of Act 3 down to the earrings worn by the performers. And scuttlebutt has it that more was spent on this one production than Opera San Jose normally spends in an entire year of four productions. There was even enough funding to permit a complete performance, no need to cut any music in order to bring the show in under 3 hours (I measured 3 hours 35 minutes).
Act I opens in the royal palace, with walls and columns decorated with historical authenticity. The palace floor consists of light brown, almost sandy, 4 ft x 4 ft tiles, which also serve well for the following scene at the seashore. Idomeneo and his shipmates have landed safely on the beach after surviving the wreck of their ship, whose mast and tattered sail can be seen upstage. The beach and ship are surrounded by a semicircular diorama.
Act 2 continues the diorama theme, but now the diorama is informed by the artwork from a piece of decorated 17th century BC pottery depicting the ships of the era. The original artwork was about 16 inches on a side; it has been very effectively recreated in large scale to fill the back of the stage. The scene change takes us back to the royal palace, but a different part, the king’s chambers, consisting of painted (though not decorated) walls and pillars, and a low bench for the king to sit on. Another scene change takes us back to the diorama, this time fairly abstract, looking crinkled cellophane. When the storm hits at the end of the act, strobe lights on the cellophane do a good job of depicting the storm.
Act 3 opens in a very simple set, apparently downstairs in the palace. It looks like a small room, seen at a 45° angle; through an open doorway (without door) we can see steps leading to the upper level of the palace. The scene changes to the most impressive one of the evening: a massive set representing the exterior of the palace of Knossos, again with walls and pillars, but there are (at least) three levels, with people standing on all the levels. (I had heard reports of four levels, but from the Grand Tier I could only see three.) In my preview I had made mention of the fact that Mozart saved the trombones for near the end, bringing them in to preface an announcement from The Voice. In this performance, we don’t get trombones, we get a thunderous statement from the Mighty Wurlitzer installed at the California Theatre, originally a 1927 movie palace. I read that for this performance they installed four new 32-foot organ pipes. (The organ could use more of them, but this performance only needed those four notes.) Following Elettra’s final aria, Idomeneo sings an aria in front of the curtain (and in front of a drop-down panel of artwork), an aria not included in my commercial recording. This aria has covered the final scene change, where they get rid of the palace and return us to the diorama, this time with three copies of a piece of art depicting bull-leaping.
Our cast:
Idomeneo: Alexander Boyer
Idamante: Betany Coffland
Ilia: Sandra Bengochea
Elettra: Jasmina Halimic
The Voice: Silas Elash
Conductor: George Cleve
Director: Brad Dalton
It was a fine cast to go along with a fine production. Everyone sang well, but I was particularly taken with the intense portrayals of Idamante and Elettra by Coffland and Halimic. Elettra is a particularly juicy role, she has a couple of rip-roaring arias to express her extreme displeasure at a Trojan slave (Ilia) rather than her, a Greek, being the one that Idamante is in love with. I had expected The Voice to be amplified and perhaps electronically modified, but Elash's sonorous bass voice filled the hall. It’s unfortunate that we got to hear The Voice for only about two minutes. (I had wondered where The Voice would spend the first two acts; he is not called for, and then does not even appear, until near the end of Act 3. As second intermission began, I ran into Elash descending from the upper balcony, on his way to his warm-up.) George Cleve, our local Mozart expert, led a first-rate orchestra.
Fantastic sets, wonderful costumes, great singing and playing, and first-class Mozart—what’s not to like? Well, the libretto, written by the chaplain at the court of Salzburg, something of an amateur at libretto-writing. Mozart’s music is superb at a moment-by-moment level, but as an entire work of art, it failed to leave a tremendous impact at the end of the evening. Somewhere between an alpha and a beta.
Wednesday, August 17, 2011
The Barber of Seville (again), Merola Opera Program, August 7 2011
Back to Herbst Theater three days later to see the other Merolini in this summer's complete opera production. The staging was of course the same as that of the other cast, with just a few minor changes. Dr. Bartolo did without a cane, which was fine; the other performance with the cane was not convincing. He sported a voluminous gray wig, rather than the previous voluminous bright red wig. Figaro got a marvelous bit of stage business early in Act 1: after Rosina “accidentally” dropped her note to “Lindoro” serenading her, Figaro somersaulted (briskly!) from the left side of the stage to the center to pick up the note, accompanied by a rapid-fire run on the harpsichord, a brief quote from the overture. Oh, what you can do with young singers!
Our cast:
Fiorello: Suchan Kim
Almaviva: Daniel Curran
Figaro: Mark Diamond
Rosina: Renée Rapier
Dr. Bartolo: John Maynard
Don Basilio: Peixin Chin
Berta: Marina Boudart Harris
Conductor: Mark Morash
Director: Roy Rallo
Diamond made a superb Figaro; Curran’s Almaviva was a couple of cuts above what I heard in the prior performance. Boudart Harris gave us a marvelously perky Berta. But my favorite was Peixin Chin, whose “La Calunnia” resonated with considerable power and depth. I am very much looking forward to hearing him at Merola’s Grand Finale—I hear that he will sing the Osmin half of a duet from The Abduction from the Seraglio, which features some notes so low that some very fine basses are unable to reach.
It’s not clear how much difference the cast made, and how much difference one more evening of on-stage experience made, but I enjoyed this performance much more than the previous one. A beta.
Our cast:
Fiorello: Suchan Kim
Almaviva: Daniel Curran
Figaro: Mark Diamond
Rosina: Renée Rapier
Dr. Bartolo: John Maynard
Don Basilio: Peixin Chin
Berta: Marina Boudart Harris
Conductor: Mark Morash
Director: Roy Rallo
Diamond made a superb Figaro; Curran’s Almaviva was a couple of cuts above what I heard in the prior performance. Boudart Harris gave us a marvelously perky Berta. But my favorite was Peixin Chin, whose “La Calunnia” resonated with considerable power and depth. I am very much looking forward to hearing him at Merola’s Grand Finale—I hear that he will sing the Osmin half of a duet from The Abduction from the Seraglio, which features some notes so low that some very fine basses are unable to reach.
It’s not clear how much difference the cast made, and how much difference one more evening of on-stage experience made, but I enjoyed this performance much more than the previous one. A beta.
Sunday, August 7, 2011
The Barber of Seville, Merola Opera Program, August 4 2011
Every summer, the Merola Opera Program invites a number (this year, 20) of young singers to San Francisco for 12 weeks of intensive study and learning. As part of the program, they present a complete opera, on stage, for the public. Last year it was The Elixir of Love; this year it was The Barber of Seville. Because there are far more “Merolini” than principal roles, there are two casts. The chorus positions are filled from the Merolini who are not singing the principal roles. The stage director is a seasoned professional, as are the conductor and the orchestra. In the orchestra I recognized Rufus Olivier, principal bassoonist for the San Francisco Opera orchestra; his son, Rufus David, also with the San Francisco Opera orchestra; and Virginia Smedberg, who has played with Opera San Jose for many years.
In this production, before the curtain goes up, Fiorello and Almaviva appear at the front of the stage, and Fiorello assists Almaviva in changing clothes from those of a Count to those of a Lindoro, the “poor student” that he will claim to be while serenading Rosina. When the curtain does go up, we see a curtain-behind-the-curtain of hanging green tinsel. “Ecco ridente” is sung in front of this green curtain, at the front of the stage. When the serenade is finished, we get the same violation of the text that we saw earlier this year in San Jose: Fiorello’s musicians are supposed to be thanking Almviva for his generosity, but here they advance menacingly on him and finally force him to hand over some greenbacks.
The arrival of Figaro is announced by a hand, holding a straight razor, peeking out from the right side of the stage. Figaro makes much of the razor, including wielding it like a rapier at one point, and practically slitting Almaviva’s throat when the latter reappears. Figaro persuades Almaviva to sing another, simpler, ad hoc serenade, the first one having been ineffective in bringing Rosina to her window. This time it works—Rosina sticks her head (just her head) out between the strands of green tinsel, and Dr. Bartolo similarly sticks his head out a few feet to the right.
After Almaviva and Figaro depart, the green tinsel curtain rises to reveal Rosina seated on a French baroque chair on top of a table, with other chairs lying on the table at strange angles, and other tables leaning up against her table. There is a 5-foot tall stack of various dishes, which she adds to during her aria “Una voce poco fa.” By the end of the aria, she has draped herself in a tablecloth, stuck plastic forks in her hair, and with her right hand raised a candelabra over head in an obvious personification of the Statue of Liberty. Clever, but completely irrelevant.
When Don Basilio enters, he is wearing headphones attached to a small rectangular box—Geiger counter? microphone?—that he holds in his hand. Both he and Dr. Bartolo are dressed and made up like caricatures of French dancing masters, with bouffant wigs and plenty of makeup. Dr. Bartolo is completely over the top with rouge and lipstick and blue eye shadow and beauty spots.
One of the challenges of a stage director is to set the chorus that concludes Act 1. Here the police force arrive carrying assault rifles that resemble AK-47s, and they spend their time in back of and on top of the tables that now extend from one side of the stage to the other, pointing their rifles at the principals at the front of the stage. Again the stage directions are ignored, as Almaviva bribes the captain of the guard instead of revealing to him (privately) his badge of nobility.
When the Act 2 curtain rises, we see eight large tables stood on end, all with their tops facing the audience, all with tablecloths featuring six-pointed stars, the angles of their points more acute than the angles of a Star of David. After Dr. Bartolo muses on recent events for a minute, Almaviva enters in another disguise, that of “Don Alonso,” a pupil of Don Basilio. He is carrying three black-and-white posters, each proclaiming in one way or another that “The end is near.” He attaches them to the upturned tables; the third one that he puts up says that “Judgment day is coming” with May 21 crossed out and October 21 beneath it. Good for a laugh, but again, its relevance to the story line escapes me. He is also carrying a roll-up piano, which he lays out on the stage and then lies on his stomach in front of it to play during the music lesson.
When Don Basilio makes his entrance, he does so by pushing over one of the upended tables. He is again wearing the headphones with the Geiger counter. During the storm, five of the remaining seven tables are pushed over by the “wind.” We are left with two adjacent tables standing in the center of the stage, with Rosina standing on a platform in back of them; this substitutes for the second floor of Dr. Bartolo’s home in a more ambitious production. Almaviva and Figaro bring a ladder onstage to climb up to Rosina; Dr. Bartolo removes it at the called-for time; Rosina and Almaviva descend by out-of-sight stairs to come to the front of the stage for the notarization. They all get to walk over the joists on the undersides of the other six large tables, which are now face-down on the stage.
I don’t expect high-budget productions from the Merola Opera Program, but I can’t help remembering the highly effective Barber of Seville that the Fremont Opera mounted a few years ago with just furniture and costumes and acting, no sets. Here, less could have been more. And why does Don Alonso’s knock sound from the right side of the stage, when he enters from the left side?
Our cast:
Fiorello: Suchan Kim
Almaviva: Heath Huberg
Figaro: Jonathon Michie
Rosina: Suzanne Rigden
Dr. Bartolo: Philippe Sly
Don Basilio: Adam Lau
Berta: Deborah Nansteel
Conductor: Mark Morash
Director: Roy Rallo
Perhaps it was just opening-night jitters, but the cast did not manage to redeem the annoying staging. Jonathon Michie (Figaro) and Philippe Sly (Dr. Bartolo) acquitted themselves well. I had heard high praise for Adam Lau (Don Basilio) but his performance did not measure up to my expectations. Suzanne Rigden had a nice set of pipes but seemed unable to coax the musicality from them that I hope will shortly be within her capabilities. I’m looking forward to hearing these singers again at the Grand Finale. Overall, a gamma.
In this production, before the curtain goes up, Fiorello and Almaviva appear at the front of the stage, and Fiorello assists Almaviva in changing clothes from those of a Count to those of a Lindoro, the “poor student” that he will claim to be while serenading Rosina. When the curtain does go up, we see a curtain-behind-the-curtain of hanging green tinsel. “Ecco ridente” is sung in front of this green curtain, at the front of the stage. When the serenade is finished, we get the same violation of the text that we saw earlier this year in San Jose: Fiorello’s musicians are supposed to be thanking Almviva for his generosity, but here they advance menacingly on him and finally force him to hand over some greenbacks.
The arrival of Figaro is announced by a hand, holding a straight razor, peeking out from the right side of the stage. Figaro makes much of the razor, including wielding it like a rapier at one point, and practically slitting Almaviva’s throat when the latter reappears. Figaro persuades Almaviva to sing another, simpler, ad hoc serenade, the first one having been ineffective in bringing Rosina to her window. This time it works—Rosina sticks her head (just her head) out between the strands of green tinsel, and Dr. Bartolo similarly sticks his head out a few feet to the right.
After Almaviva and Figaro depart, the green tinsel curtain rises to reveal Rosina seated on a French baroque chair on top of a table, with other chairs lying on the table at strange angles, and other tables leaning up against her table. There is a 5-foot tall stack of various dishes, which she adds to during her aria “Una voce poco fa.” By the end of the aria, she has draped herself in a tablecloth, stuck plastic forks in her hair, and with her right hand raised a candelabra over head in an obvious personification of the Statue of Liberty. Clever, but completely irrelevant.
When Don Basilio enters, he is wearing headphones attached to a small rectangular box—Geiger counter? microphone?—that he holds in his hand. Both he and Dr. Bartolo are dressed and made up like caricatures of French dancing masters, with bouffant wigs and plenty of makeup. Dr. Bartolo is completely over the top with rouge and lipstick and blue eye shadow and beauty spots.
One of the challenges of a stage director is to set the chorus that concludes Act 1. Here the police force arrive carrying assault rifles that resemble AK-47s, and they spend their time in back of and on top of the tables that now extend from one side of the stage to the other, pointing their rifles at the principals at the front of the stage. Again the stage directions are ignored, as Almaviva bribes the captain of the guard instead of revealing to him (privately) his badge of nobility.
When the Act 2 curtain rises, we see eight large tables stood on end, all with their tops facing the audience, all with tablecloths featuring six-pointed stars, the angles of their points more acute than the angles of a Star of David. After Dr. Bartolo muses on recent events for a minute, Almaviva enters in another disguise, that of “Don Alonso,” a pupil of Don Basilio. He is carrying three black-and-white posters, each proclaiming in one way or another that “The end is near.” He attaches them to the upturned tables; the third one that he puts up says that “Judgment day is coming” with May 21 crossed out and October 21 beneath it. Good for a laugh, but again, its relevance to the story line escapes me. He is also carrying a roll-up piano, which he lays out on the stage and then lies on his stomach in front of it to play during the music lesson.
When Don Basilio makes his entrance, he does so by pushing over one of the upended tables. He is again wearing the headphones with the Geiger counter. During the storm, five of the remaining seven tables are pushed over by the “wind.” We are left with two adjacent tables standing in the center of the stage, with Rosina standing on a platform in back of them; this substitutes for the second floor of Dr. Bartolo’s home in a more ambitious production. Almaviva and Figaro bring a ladder onstage to climb up to Rosina; Dr. Bartolo removes it at the called-for time; Rosina and Almaviva descend by out-of-sight stairs to come to the front of the stage for the notarization. They all get to walk over the joists on the undersides of the other six large tables, which are now face-down on the stage.
I don’t expect high-budget productions from the Merola Opera Program, but I can’t help remembering the highly effective Barber of Seville that the Fremont Opera mounted a few years ago with just furniture and costumes and acting, no sets. Here, less could have been more. And why does Don Alonso’s knock sound from the right side of the stage, when he enters from the left side?
Our cast:
Fiorello: Suchan Kim
Almaviva: Heath Huberg
Figaro: Jonathon Michie
Rosina: Suzanne Rigden
Dr. Bartolo: Philippe Sly
Don Basilio: Adam Lau
Berta: Deborah Nansteel
Conductor: Mark Morash
Director: Roy Rallo
Perhaps it was just opening-night jitters, but the cast did not manage to redeem the annoying staging. Jonathon Michie (Figaro) and Philippe Sly (Dr. Bartolo) acquitted themselves well. I had heard high praise for Adam Lau (Don Basilio) but his performance did not measure up to my expectations. Suzanne Rigden had a nice set of pipes but seemed unable to coax the musicality from them that I hope will shortly be within her capabilities. I’m looking forward to hearing these singers again at the Grand Finale. Overall, a gamma.
Friday, July 15, 2011
Götterdämmerung, San Francisco Opera, July 3 2011
You know that a production has taken a left turn somewhere when the staging matches the libretto so poorly that they have to take serious liberties with the supertitles. And that’s what happens in San Francisco Opera’s staging of the first prologue to Götterdämmerung, with the Norns. Wagner sets the action on the Valkyries’ rock, where Brünnhilde was laid down to sleep on Wednesday evening and Siegfried awakened her on Friday evening. It’s now Sunday afternoon, and the Norns are supposed to be tossing the rope of fate from one to the other and tying it variously around a pine tree, a fir tree, and a rock. Wagner has the Third Norn begin what little action there is with “Why don’t we spin and sing?” In San Francisco, the scene takes place on, or within, a printed circuit board that is projected on the scrim. On the floor there is a massive pile of thick cables, clearly reminiscent of the cables underneath the raised floor of any computer room that has been in use for years, and the Third Norn sings “Why don’t we switch the cable now?” Later on, the supertitle reads “I used to lay the cable by the fir tree.” When the rope of fate frays and breaks, there is a flash of light from the end of the cable, and we read “The connection is broken!” as we hear “Es riß! Es riß! Es riß!” (“It tore!”) All the while, the Norns are wearing garish green surgical gowns and skullcaps, with black aprons in front, and are sporting dark sunglasses.
At the end of the first prologue, the Norns descend “to mother” and the scene changes to the Valkyries’ rock, as called for. It is the same set as at the end of Siegfried, with the concrete structures of the Die Walküre set showing the ravages of time.
Act 1 proper begins in the Hall of the Gibichungs. The structure is largely plate-glass windows supported by thick stainless steel frames; the furniture consists of a couple of white modern-style sofas, almost Mies van der Rohe in appearance, and a small bar. In the background an oil refinery can barely be discerned. Act 1 ends back at the Valkyries’ rock, with Waltraute’s entreaty to Brünnhilde to give the ring back to the Rhinemaidens and “Gunther’s” conquest of Brünnhilde.
Act 2 opens with the appearance of Alberich and his question to Hagen, “Are you sleeping, my son?” Here the extended orchestral introduction is given a strange accompaniment on stage. Hagen and Gutrune are sitting on a large Mies van der Rohe-style bed; Hagen is apparently channel-surfing by pointing a remote control at the audience. When he clicks it, a red LED on its end illuminates, and a brief rectangular flash appears on the scrim, though we don’t actually see any TV images. Gutrune tries her hand with the remote control, then leaves and Hagen curls up in time for Alberich’s appearance. After the dialogue between father and son, Hagen goes back to sleep, and Alberich picks up the remote control and appears to be as puzzled by it as any 1900-era person might be. It’s humorous, but we don’t need humor here.
Act 2 continues with a more public place in the Hall of the Gibichungs. The raked metal grate stage that underlies every scene of this Ring is there, surmounted by a horizontal white platform that occupies most of the right half of the stage. On the left, a few white steps descend to the metal grate floor; on the right, more white steps ascend to the edge of the stage. On the left there is a long low bench extending from downstage to upstage.
In Act 3 the destruction of Nature continues. The Rhine has apparently run dry. The river bed is festooned with empty plastic bottles, old tires, and other detritus; toward the rear is a discarded camper shell. The Rhinemaidens appear with large black plastic garbage bags and begin to fill them with the plastic water bottles. When Siegfried enters, he is carrying a rifle in addition to Notung. The curtain drops for the scene change in which all the river bed junk is removed. Three pairs of lights seem to approach from the rear, but when the curtain goes up, there are no jeeps to be seen. Siegfried, Gunther, and Hagen are dressed in bright orange coveralls, while the rest of the hunting party is dressed in camouflage. The spoils of the hunt are brought in on handcarts, flat platforms with an axle and rubber tires located very near the end of the cart. Siegfried’s body will be carried back to the Hall of the Gibichungs on one of these carts.
The final scene is set on a bare stage, just the metal grate floor that we are quite familiar with by now. Siegfried’s body is brought in on one of the handcarts. At the end the body is unceremoniously dumped over the edge at the back of the stage while “gasoline” is poured from jerry cans over the now out-of-sight body. Hagen enters with his cry of “Zurück von dem Ring!” (“Get back from the Ring!”), and rather than drowning him the Rhinemaidens whip out a bright yellow plastic bag and suffocate him with it. More “message,” I guess.
Our cast:
First Norn: Ronnita Miller
Second Norn: Daveda Karanas
Third Norn: Heidi Melton
Brünnhilde: Nina Stemme
Siegfried: Ian Storey
Gunther: Gerd Grochowski
Gutrune: Melissa Citro
Hagen: Andrea Silvestrelli
Waltraute: Daveda Karanas
Alberich: Gordon Hawkins
Woglinde: Stacey Tappan
Wellgunde: Lauren McNeese
Flosshilde: Renée Tatum
Conductor: Donald Runnicles
Director: Francesca Zambello
I continue to be a big fan of Andrea Silvestrelli. His Hagen was appropriately menacing, and his Hagen’s Watch solo near the end of Act 1 was spine-tingling. Gordon Hawkins shone in his limited role as Alberich, just as he did in Siegfried. Nina Stemme performed solidly as Brünnhilde all afternoon long. Ian Storey was OK as Siegfried. The orchestra under Runnicles’s direction was in top form. The curtain call featured something I had never seen before: the entire orchestra was on stage, with the principal horn player in the lineup in front, next to Runnicles.
So what am I going to remember from this, my eleventh Ring cycle? I will remember Brandon Jovanovich’s remarkable debut as Siegmund. I will remember Andrea Silvestrelli’s commanding presence as Fasolt and as Hagen, and wish that he could have sung Hunding as well. I will remember Jay Hunter Morriss’s well-acted Siegfried, and hope that his being called up from his role as cover will be the start of something big for him. I will remember the glorious sound at my seat in the balcony. And even though I didn’t care for it (perhaps because I didn’t care for it), Francesca Zambello’s excesses with the staging will be memorable. Everything considered, a beta-plus.
At the end of the first prologue, the Norns descend “to mother” and the scene changes to the Valkyries’ rock, as called for. It is the same set as at the end of Siegfried, with the concrete structures of the Die Walküre set showing the ravages of time.
Act 1 proper begins in the Hall of the Gibichungs. The structure is largely plate-glass windows supported by thick stainless steel frames; the furniture consists of a couple of white modern-style sofas, almost Mies van der Rohe in appearance, and a small bar. In the background an oil refinery can barely be discerned. Act 1 ends back at the Valkyries’ rock, with Waltraute’s entreaty to Brünnhilde to give the ring back to the Rhinemaidens and “Gunther’s” conquest of Brünnhilde.
Act 2 opens with the appearance of Alberich and his question to Hagen, “Are you sleeping, my son?” Here the extended orchestral introduction is given a strange accompaniment on stage. Hagen and Gutrune are sitting on a large Mies van der Rohe-style bed; Hagen is apparently channel-surfing by pointing a remote control at the audience. When he clicks it, a red LED on its end illuminates, and a brief rectangular flash appears on the scrim, though we don’t actually see any TV images. Gutrune tries her hand with the remote control, then leaves and Hagen curls up in time for Alberich’s appearance. After the dialogue between father and son, Hagen goes back to sleep, and Alberich picks up the remote control and appears to be as puzzled by it as any 1900-era person might be. It’s humorous, but we don’t need humor here.
Act 2 continues with a more public place in the Hall of the Gibichungs. The raked metal grate stage that underlies every scene of this Ring is there, surmounted by a horizontal white platform that occupies most of the right half of the stage. On the left, a few white steps descend to the metal grate floor; on the right, more white steps ascend to the edge of the stage. On the left there is a long low bench extending from downstage to upstage.
In Act 3 the destruction of Nature continues. The Rhine has apparently run dry. The river bed is festooned with empty plastic bottles, old tires, and other detritus; toward the rear is a discarded camper shell. The Rhinemaidens appear with large black plastic garbage bags and begin to fill them with the plastic water bottles. When Siegfried enters, he is carrying a rifle in addition to Notung. The curtain drops for the scene change in which all the river bed junk is removed. Three pairs of lights seem to approach from the rear, but when the curtain goes up, there are no jeeps to be seen. Siegfried, Gunther, and Hagen are dressed in bright orange coveralls, while the rest of the hunting party is dressed in camouflage. The spoils of the hunt are brought in on handcarts, flat platforms with an axle and rubber tires located very near the end of the cart. Siegfried’s body will be carried back to the Hall of the Gibichungs on one of these carts.
The final scene is set on a bare stage, just the metal grate floor that we are quite familiar with by now. Siegfried’s body is brought in on one of the handcarts. At the end the body is unceremoniously dumped over the edge at the back of the stage while “gasoline” is poured from jerry cans over the now out-of-sight body. Hagen enters with his cry of “Zurück von dem Ring!” (“Get back from the Ring!”), and rather than drowning him the Rhinemaidens whip out a bright yellow plastic bag and suffocate him with it. More “message,” I guess.
Our cast:
First Norn: Ronnita Miller
Second Norn: Daveda Karanas
Third Norn: Heidi Melton
Brünnhilde: Nina Stemme
Siegfried: Ian Storey
Gunther: Gerd Grochowski
Gutrune: Melissa Citro
Hagen: Andrea Silvestrelli
Waltraute: Daveda Karanas
Alberich: Gordon Hawkins
Woglinde: Stacey Tappan
Wellgunde: Lauren McNeese
Flosshilde: Renée Tatum
Conductor: Donald Runnicles
Director: Francesca Zambello
I continue to be a big fan of Andrea Silvestrelli. His Hagen was appropriately menacing, and his Hagen’s Watch solo near the end of Act 1 was spine-tingling. Gordon Hawkins shone in his limited role as Alberich, just as he did in Siegfried. Nina Stemme performed solidly as Brünnhilde all afternoon long. Ian Storey was OK as Siegfried. The orchestra under Runnicles’s direction was in top form. The curtain call featured something I had never seen before: the entire orchestra was on stage, with the principal horn player in the lineup in front, next to Runnicles.
So what am I going to remember from this, my eleventh Ring cycle? I will remember Brandon Jovanovich’s remarkable debut as Siegmund. I will remember Andrea Silvestrelli’s commanding presence as Fasolt and as Hagen, and wish that he could have sung Hunding as well. I will remember Jay Hunter Morriss’s well-acted Siegfried, and hope that his being called up from his role as cover will be the start of something big for him. I will remember the glorious sound at my seat in the balcony. And even though I didn’t care for it (perhaps because I didn’t care for it), Francesca Zambello’s excesses with the staging will be memorable. Everything considered, a beta-plus.
Tuesday, July 5, 2011
Siegfried, San Francisco Opera, July 1 2011
A day off for the performers (and the audience!), then back into San Francisco for Siegfried, the third installment of the Ring cycle. Advance photos had prepared me for the very unusual setting of Act 1. Mime and Siegfried are living in a small trailer, no more than 20 feet long, with most of its right side (facing the audience) cut away to reveal the dinette and the bare-bones kitchen; an avocado-colored stove sits on the ground just outside the trailer. I never saw it properly illuminated, but again thanks to advance photos I knew that right next to the stove were two cases of Rheingold beer. In the background, consistent with the industrial nature of the production, there is the silhouette of an electrical substation. To the right of the trailer are the tools that Siegfried will use to reforge Notung: an anvil that looks more like a V-8 engine block, a bellows, and an old bathtub. Yes, Siegfried does split the anvil at the conclusion of the act.
Fafner’s cave is located in an industrial alley. The side of the building has four sliding metal doors with windows along the top; in the alley there is an industrial-strength table with various objects on it. Among these objects are a 2-foot length of galvanized pipe, and a brace-and-bit that Siegfried will use to bore holes in its length in his attempt to fashion an instrument to echo the woodbird. The woodbird is a soprano dressed in a red gown, who walks to and fro on the catwalk above the sliding metal doors, and eventually descends to stage level. When Fafner responds to Siegfried’s horn call, two of the doors open and a very large metal “monster” (that’s what the supertitles say, rather than “dragon”) emerges. It’s supposed to be an industrial-scale trash compactor. Advance information says that when Siegfried stabs the monster, it bleeds oil rather than blood, but I couldn’t see that from my vantage point.
For Act 3 we are back in the valley of the Rhine, with two-dimensional cutouts representing the canyon walls, but there is no Rhine or any suggestion of it, just the bare metal grate floor that is a feature of all of the acts. After Siegfried breaks Wotan’s spear with his sword, the curtain comes down to allow a scene change to Brünnhilde’s rock, where we left her at the end of Die Walküre. The gun emplacement where she was put to sleep must have been made of really cheap concrete, for in the 18 years that it has taken Siegfried to grow to (the beginnings of) adulthood, much of the concrete has deteriorated significantly—it’s a different set, although it echoes the previous set.
Our cast:
Mime: David Cangelosi
Siegfried: Jay Hunter Morris
The Wanderer: Mark Delavan
Alberich: Gordon Hawkins
Forest Bird: Stacey Tappan
Fafner: Daniel Sumegi
Erda: Ronnita Miller
Brünnhilde: Nina Stemme
Conductor: Donald Runnicles
Director: Francesca Zambello
I hope that this role will be a breakthrough for Jay Hunter Morris. He was originally scheduled to cover Ian Storey’s Siegfried in the final two operas, but Storey suffered a medical problem that interfered with his study of both roles, so he took Götterdämmerung and Morris got to sing the Siegfried Siegfried. While not quite as vocally impressive as Brandon Jovanovich (Siegmund) had been two evenings earlier, he nevertheless sang quite well and did a superb job of acting the part of a teenage boy. It was particularly delightful to watch his facial expressions as he is trying to figure out what to do with this sleeping person who is “not a man.” David Cangelosi was also a very active performer, turning cartwheels and somersaults as he anticipates feeding a poisoned drink to Siegfried after the battle. Gordon Hawkins could give his all in the short amount of time that is he onstage as Alberich. Mark Delavan continued to be competent as the Wanderer. And Nina Stemme just gets better and better. Act 3 is when the orchestra really comes into its own, after Wagner takes 12 years off to write Tristan und Isolde and Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, and returns to the Ring with astoundingly advanced compositional skills. Donald Runnicles led the orchestra in a tour de force performance. Overall, quite good, but not quite good enough for an alpha.
Fafner’s cave is located in an industrial alley. The side of the building has four sliding metal doors with windows along the top; in the alley there is an industrial-strength table with various objects on it. Among these objects are a 2-foot length of galvanized pipe, and a brace-and-bit that Siegfried will use to bore holes in its length in his attempt to fashion an instrument to echo the woodbird. The woodbird is a soprano dressed in a red gown, who walks to and fro on the catwalk above the sliding metal doors, and eventually descends to stage level. When Fafner responds to Siegfried’s horn call, two of the doors open and a very large metal “monster” (that’s what the supertitles say, rather than “dragon”) emerges. It’s supposed to be an industrial-scale trash compactor. Advance information says that when Siegfried stabs the monster, it bleeds oil rather than blood, but I couldn’t see that from my vantage point.
For Act 3 we are back in the valley of the Rhine, with two-dimensional cutouts representing the canyon walls, but there is no Rhine or any suggestion of it, just the bare metal grate floor that is a feature of all of the acts. After Siegfried breaks Wotan’s spear with his sword, the curtain comes down to allow a scene change to Brünnhilde’s rock, where we left her at the end of Die Walküre. The gun emplacement where she was put to sleep must have been made of really cheap concrete, for in the 18 years that it has taken Siegfried to grow to (the beginnings of) adulthood, much of the concrete has deteriorated significantly—it’s a different set, although it echoes the previous set.
Our cast:
Mime: David Cangelosi
Siegfried: Jay Hunter Morris
The Wanderer: Mark Delavan
Alberich: Gordon Hawkins
Forest Bird: Stacey Tappan
Fafner: Daniel Sumegi
Erda: Ronnita Miller
Brünnhilde: Nina Stemme
Conductor: Donald Runnicles
Director: Francesca Zambello
I hope that this role will be a breakthrough for Jay Hunter Morris. He was originally scheduled to cover Ian Storey’s Siegfried in the final two operas, but Storey suffered a medical problem that interfered with his study of both roles, so he took Götterdämmerung and Morris got to sing the Siegfried Siegfried. While not quite as vocally impressive as Brandon Jovanovich (Siegmund) had been two evenings earlier, he nevertheless sang quite well and did a superb job of acting the part of a teenage boy. It was particularly delightful to watch his facial expressions as he is trying to figure out what to do with this sleeping person who is “not a man.” David Cangelosi was also a very active performer, turning cartwheels and somersaults as he anticipates feeding a poisoned drink to Siegfried after the battle. Gordon Hawkins could give his all in the short amount of time that is he onstage as Alberich. Mark Delavan continued to be competent as the Wanderer. And Nina Stemme just gets better and better. Act 3 is when the orchestra really comes into its own, after Wagner takes 12 years off to write Tristan und Isolde and Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg, and returns to the Ring with astoundingly advanced compositional skills. Donald Runnicles led the orchestra in a tour de force performance. Overall, quite good, but not quite good enough for an alpha.
Monday, July 4, 2011
Die Walküre, San Francisco Opera, June 29 2011
As befits a proper Ring cycle, it’s back to San Francisco the day after Das Rheingold for the second (and most popular) installment, Die Walküre, the one in which Wotan causes the death of his son Siegmund and banishes his daughter Brünnhilde for trying to save him, all to some of the most glorious music ever written.
Act 1 opens with the orchestra portraying Siegmund running through a violent storm, with an immediate musical tie-in to Donner’s “He da! He da, he do!” of the end of Das Rheingold. Here our attention is diverted from the orchestra by projections depicting roiling seas and a run through the redwoods. I preferred to shut my eyes and immerse myself in the music. When the curtain goes up, we see the outside of Hunding’s hut, actually a simple frame house that I would place in the 1930s South. The hearth at which Siegmund collapses is a large barbecue pit, just outside the house. When Sieglinde invites him inside, the side of the house is whisked into the rafters, and we get a diagonal perspective of Hunding’s living room, with taxidermied deer on the walls, a tall hutch with domestic knickknacks, a sword hanging on the wall, and a two-dimensional cutout of a large tree in the middle. There is no sword in the tree—that comes later, about the time that Siegmund cries out, “Father! Where is the sword you promised me?” The sword has apparently been hanging vertically behind the tree; now it falls to the right, with an audible “clack!”, and its hilt is now visible. Sorry, but that’s the least successful sword that I’ve ever seen. When it’s time for Winterstürme and Du bist der Lenz, the two sides of the living room are pulled apart so that the audience sees them edge-on (and so they are as out of sight as possible) and a projection of a very large full moon appears at the back of the stage. After they (yes, here Siegmund and Sieglinde together) pull Notung out of the tree, the tree is whisked into the rafters, giving the pair plenty of room to paw one another before rushing off upstage.
Act 2 brings us inside Valhalla for the confrontation between Wotan and Fricka. Wotan has an office high above a large industrial city, with its skyscrapers far below and embedded in industrial pollution, as seen through half a dozen tall plate-glass windows. In front of the windows is a loooong black table, which Wotan uses as his desk. For scene 3 we move to a no-man’s land underneath a decaying freeway, littered with old tires, an old bench seat, and other detritus of urban life.
Act 3, which opens with “The Ride of the Valkyries,” is the most successful. We see a large concrete structure that echoes the gun emplacements overlooking the Golden Gate, with a circular gun platform in the middle, a concrete wall in back that slopes down to the right and then continues sloping down as it comes downstage; on the left there is a metal staircase that descends downstage. These Valkyries are World War II paratroopers, dressed in Amelia Earhart-like garb. Doubles slide down ropes, starting high above the middle of the stage and landing at stage level, just behind the curtain walls; the singers then rush on stage, dragging their parachutes behind them. (The audience applauded, both at the appearance of the first paratroopers and again at the end of The Ride.) In lieu of bodies or body parts of dead heroes, the Valkyries carry close-cropped photos of American soldiers killed in the Civil War, World Wars I and II, and Iraq and Afghanistan. There are also photos of Hunding and Siegmund (despite the fact that Wotan tells Brünnhilde that he has no use of Hunding in Valhalla). The fire that Wotan causes to spring up around Brünnhilde surrounds her on only three sides: lines of gas flames proceed up the metal staircase, down the back edge of the rear concrete wall, and then down toward stage level on the right.
Our cast:
Siegmund: Brandon Jovanovich
Sieglinde: Heidi Melton
Hunding: Daniel Sumegi
Wotan: Mark Delavan
Brünnhilde: Nina Stemme
Fricka: Elizabeth Bishop
Gerhilde: Sara Gartland
Helmwige: Tamara Wapinsky
Ortlinde: Melissa Citro
Waltraute: Daveda Karanas
Rossweisse: Lauren McNeese
Siegrune: Maya Lahyani
Grimgerde: Renée Tatum
Schwertleite: Cybele Gouverneur
Conductor: Donald Runicles
Director: Francesca Zambello
And what a cast it was! I was tremendously impressed with Brandon Jovanovich’s Siegmund, a good-looking heartthrob of a guy with a clear, powerful tenor to match. I can remember being equally impressed by two previous Siegmunds: Placido Domingo in 2000, and Jon Vickers in 1976. He may have tired just a little bit right at the end of Act 1, but the audience exploded in the biggest burst of applause in this entire cycle when the Act 1 music concluded. Heidi Melton certainly deserved some of it, but I was cheering for Jovanovich. He is on record as having a Lohengrin in his future; I would love to see that in San Francisco!
Also worthy of particular note was Elizabeth Bishop’s majestic Fricka. As a group, the Valkyries were outstanding. It was as though the chorus master, with only eight women to guide, could spend lots of time with each one. Much praise is being heaped on Nina Stemme’s Brünnhilde, and deservedly so, but I found myself thinking on occasion, hmmm, that note would be worthy of Rita Hunter. Not all of them, but some of them. Rita Hunter was the Brünnhilde in my very first complete Ring cycle, and she thrilled the entire Seattle audience with one of the greatest voices I have ever heard. It got me to wondering: if your first Brünnhilde was Birgit Nilsson, or Kirsten Flagstad, would any other Brünnhilde ever measure up? That may be the box that I am in.
Act 1, an alpha. Acts 2 and 3, not quite.
Act 1 opens with the orchestra portraying Siegmund running through a violent storm, with an immediate musical tie-in to Donner’s “He da! He da, he do!” of the end of Das Rheingold. Here our attention is diverted from the orchestra by projections depicting roiling seas and a run through the redwoods. I preferred to shut my eyes and immerse myself in the music. When the curtain goes up, we see the outside of Hunding’s hut, actually a simple frame house that I would place in the 1930s South. The hearth at which Siegmund collapses is a large barbecue pit, just outside the house. When Sieglinde invites him inside, the side of the house is whisked into the rafters, and we get a diagonal perspective of Hunding’s living room, with taxidermied deer on the walls, a tall hutch with domestic knickknacks, a sword hanging on the wall, and a two-dimensional cutout of a large tree in the middle. There is no sword in the tree—that comes later, about the time that Siegmund cries out, “Father! Where is the sword you promised me?” The sword has apparently been hanging vertically behind the tree; now it falls to the right, with an audible “clack!”, and its hilt is now visible. Sorry, but that’s the least successful sword that I’ve ever seen. When it’s time for Winterstürme and Du bist der Lenz, the two sides of the living room are pulled apart so that the audience sees them edge-on (and so they are as out of sight as possible) and a projection of a very large full moon appears at the back of the stage. After they (yes, here Siegmund and Sieglinde together) pull Notung out of the tree, the tree is whisked into the rafters, giving the pair plenty of room to paw one another before rushing off upstage.
Act 2 brings us inside Valhalla for the confrontation between Wotan and Fricka. Wotan has an office high above a large industrial city, with its skyscrapers far below and embedded in industrial pollution, as seen through half a dozen tall plate-glass windows. In front of the windows is a loooong black table, which Wotan uses as his desk. For scene 3 we move to a no-man’s land underneath a decaying freeway, littered with old tires, an old bench seat, and other detritus of urban life.
Act 3, which opens with “The Ride of the Valkyries,” is the most successful. We see a large concrete structure that echoes the gun emplacements overlooking the Golden Gate, with a circular gun platform in the middle, a concrete wall in back that slopes down to the right and then continues sloping down as it comes downstage; on the left there is a metal staircase that descends downstage. These Valkyries are World War II paratroopers, dressed in Amelia Earhart-like garb. Doubles slide down ropes, starting high above the middle of the stage and landing at stage level, just behind the curtain walls; the singers then rush on stage, dragging their parachutes behind them. (The audience applauded, both at the appearance of the first paratroopers and again at the end of The Ride.) In lieu of bodies or body parts of dead heroes, the Valkyries carry close-cropped photos of American soldiers killed in the Civil War, World Wars I and II, and Iraq and Afghanistan. There are also photos of Hunding and Siegmund (despite the fact that Wotan tells Brünnhilde that he has no use of Hunding in Valhalla). The fire that Wotan causes to spring up around Brünnhilde surrounds her on only three sides: lines of gas flames proceed up the metal staircase, down the back edge of the rear concrete wall, and then down toward stage level on the right.
Our cast:
Siegmund: Brandon Jovanovich
Sieglinde: Heidi Melton
Hunding: Daniel Sumegi
Wotan: Mark Delavan
Brünnhilde: Nina Stemme
Fricka: Elizabeth Bishop
Gerhilde: Sara Gartland
Helmwige: Tamara Wapinsky
Ortlinde: Melissa Citro
Waltraute: Daveda Karanas
Rossweisse: Lauren McNeese
Siegrune: Maya Lahyani
Grimgerde: Renée Tatum
Schwertleite: Cybele Gouverneur
Conductor: Donald Runicles
Director: Francesca Zambello
And what a cast it was! I was tremendously impressed with Brandon Jovanovich’s Siegmund, a good-looking heartthrob of a guy with a clear, powerful tenor to match. I can remember being equally impressed by two previous Siegmunds: Placido Domingo in 2000, and Jon Vickers in 1976. He may have tired just a little bit right at the end of Act 1, but the audience exploded in the biggest burst of applause in this entire cycle when the Act 1 music concluded. Heidi Melton certainly deserved some of it, but I was cheering for Jovanovich. He is on record as having a Lohengrin in his future; I would love to see that in San Francisco!
Also worthy of particular note was Elizabeth Bishop’s majestic Fricka. As a group, the Valkyries were outstanding. It was as though the chorus master, with only eight women to guide, could spend lots of time with each one. Much praise is being heaped on Nina Stemme’s Brünnhilde, and deservedly so, but I found myself thinking on occasion, hmmm, that note would be worthy of Rita Hunter. Not all of them, but some of them. Rita Hunter was the Brünnhilde in my very first complete Ring cycle, and she thrilled the entire Seattle audience with one of the greatest voices I have ever heard. It got me to wondering: if your first Brünnhilde was Birgit Nilsson, or Kirsten Flagstad, would any other Brünnhilde ever measure up? That may be the box that I am in.
Act 1, an alpha. Acts 2 and 3, not quite.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)